M·A·C is taking us back to the good old days of comic book romance with this limited edition Archie’s Girls collection. The pink and red color themes reflect Betty’s girl-next-door charm and Veronica’s vivacious allure.

I stumbled upon this adorable, Valentine’s Day collection when I arrived in the office this morning, and I couldn’t wait to take a closer look. The retro packaging immediately caught my attention and sent me into a nostalgic frenzy. Betty or Veronica? Well, as far as Archie is concerned, I always thought he’d be better off with the sweet blonde. But as far as this collection, I’m completely torn. The Betty side consists of pretty pastel peaches and pinks, while the Veronica side features sultry shades of red and purple. Is it wrong to want to be Betty by day and Veronica by night?!

These contrasting collections contain everything from lipsticks to pigments. It even offers two eye shadow palettes, one for Betty (Caramel Sunday), and one for Veronica (Spoiled Rich). But I think my favorite pieces are the two beauty powders—both are matte with pearl finishes and have festive Valentine hearts carved in the center. Archie’s Girls will be available in stores on February 7, or online now!

Which love-struck comic teen are you most like, Betty or Veronica?

More From Real Beauty:

Valentine's Gift Guide for Him

Winter Skincare Tips

How to Fake 8 Hours of Sleep