TheBalm Cast Your Shadow Palette
While you may have a hard time tracking down this limited-edition, Muppets-themed compact (we're sad to report it sold out almost immediately), it's worth stalking eBay to try to snag one. The compact features 16 colorful eye shadows, three multipurpose lip-and-cheek creams, and a duel-ended brush. Just like Kermit tries to reunite the squad in the new film (spoiler!), use these bright colors together to get the best results.