Winner: Maybelline New York EyeStudio Color Plush Silk Eye Shadow
We always say that you can find some of the best makeup at the drugstore, but even we were surprised that our testers chose this affordable palette over department store versions that cost triple the amount. The texture of the powder shadow is so satin-y that it feels like a cream and you get four shimmery shades to mix and match.
Maybelline New York EyeStudio Color Plush Silk Eye Shadow, $9.99 at drugstore.com
See our full list of 2010 Gold Star winners!