C.O. Bigelow Lemon Lip Balm
The Claim: 100% natural lemon flavor packs a tangy punch, while shea butter targets flakiness and Vitamin C nourishes your pout.
The Truth: If you're a fan of anything lemon, like our tester, then this is the balm for you. "The lemony smell first attracted me to this product," notes the tester. "I think this would feel especially great on sunburned lips."