Halloween Candy: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly

When it comes to candy, this upcoming holiday season is like a game of Monopoly — strips of properties peppered with green houses and red hotels. One roll of the dice and your load of paper money (or healthy eating plan) is diminished. With the help of Sasson Moulavi, M.D. (Dr. Sass), medical director of Smart for Life, we found the Halloween candy that's okay to nibble on and the ones to avoid like landing on Park Place and Boardwalk with hotels on each.

By Ariana Finlayson

Share
candy corn
Elizabeth Griffin
Back Next

Candy Corn

Rundown: This candy is high in sugar, which causes an insulin boost and a sugar spike that makes you want more. In studies, foods high in sugar have caused a chemical change in the brain similar to that caused by drugs.

Calories, fats, and sugar: 22 pieces (serving): 140 calories, no fat or saturated fat, 28 grams sugar.

Verdict: Stay away. Since these candies don't normally come preportioned, having willpower will be hard when it's so easy to keep reaching for them by the handful.

dum dum lollipops
Elizabeth Griffin
Back Next

Dum-Dum Pops

Rundown: After just a few licks, we tend to crunch right down on these. They can be hell on teeth, especially since the hard candy can get stuck in molars.

Calories, fats, and sugar: 2 pops (serving): 51 calories, no fat or saturated fat, 10 grams sugar.

Verdict: Best bet for calorie counters who need a tiny sweet fix. Just remember to keep licking.

milky way fun size bars
Elizabeth Griffin
Back Next

Milky Way Fun-Size Bars

Rundown: This chocolate has a gooey caramel center, which stays longer in your teeth and provides opportunity for cavities to grow.

Calories, fats, and sugar: 2 fun-size bars (serving): 150 calories, 6 grams fat, 4 grams saturated fat, 20 grams sugar.

Verdict: Avoid these, mostly because of the steep saturated fat count. There are better-for-you chocolate bars to choose from.

m and m fun size
Elizabeth Griffin
Back Next

M&M's Fun Size Pouch

Rundown: Believe it or not, these are not a bad choice, since the peanuts have protein to pack some nutritional value. (Dark chocolate is even better because of the antioxidant benefits.)

Calories, fats, and sugar: 1 pouch (serving): 90 calories, 5 grams fat, 1.7 grams saturated fat, 9 grams sugar.

Verdict: Thumbs-up.

Elizabeth Griffin
Back Next

Reese's Peanut Butter Cup

Rundown: The combo of peanut butter and milk chocolate gives this treat a high fat count.

Calories, fats, and sugar: 1 cup (serving): 88 calories, 5 grams fat, 2 grams saturated fat, 8 grams sugar.

Verdict: Stay away, since the grams of fat and calories can add up quickly. Opt for Peanut M&Ms if you need a nutty chocolate fix.

Elizabeth Griffin
Back Next

Skittles

Rundown: These chewy candies are high in fructose corn syrup and can also stick to dental work.

Calories, fats, and sugar: 1 fun-size packet (serving): 60 calories, 0.67 grams of fat, no saturated fat, 11 grams sugar.

Verdict: Okay to nibble, as long as you stick to one pack. Although they're low in fat, the sugar and calories can add up.

Elizabeth Griffin
Back Next

3 Musketeers Fun-Size Bar

Rundown: Their fluffy texture (read: air) makes these bars feel substantial. No caramel is a plus.

Calories, fats, and sugar: 3 fun-size bars (serving): 190 calories, 6 grams fat, 4 grams saturated fat, 30 grams sugar.

Verdict: The most-bang-for-your-calories choice: Space these bars out throughout your day.

Elizabeth Griffin
Back Next

Tootsie Roll Midgees

Rundown: Their gooey, ultra-chewy composition can stick to molars and between teeth. On the plus side, they're low in fat.

Calories, fats, and sugar: 6 pieces (serving): 140 calories, 3 grams fat, no saturated fat, 21 grams sugar.

Verdict: Okay in our book. These guys take a while to chew, thus extending your sugar indulgence.

Elizabeth Griffin
Back Next

Twizzlers

Rundown: These chewy twists can be hard to bite. They look simple, but zero grams of fiber and protein makes them a pure sugar bomb that turns to fat.

Calories, fats, and sugar: 4 pieces (serving): 150 calories, 1 gram fat, no saturated fat, 21 grams sugar.

Verdict: Pass them up: That's a ton of calories for only four ropes.

Elizabeth Griffin
Back Next

Sugar-Free Candy

Dr. Sass is adamant about children and adults not indulging in high-fructose corn syrup candy, juices, and sodas during this festive season. And although you can't really tell yourself that running house to house with your pillowcase is exercise, opt for sugar-free versions of treats or gum if you must indulge.

Our pick: Sugar-Free Lifesavers

Calories, fats, and sugar: 5 pieces (serving): 30 calories, no fats or sugar.

Verdict: Although they may not be available at Walmart by the lot, sugar-free versions of your favorite candies will be your best options. (Beware of low-calorie or low-fat versions, as the flavor could be substituted in other areas, such as sugar.)

Return to Slideshow

Related Links