Gretchen Mol

We say: Unfortunately, this is a bad version of a Greek goddess. We weren't impressed with her white and gold dress, which looked more like a band costume. That coupled with a less-than-flattering updo and natural makeup make her look blah instead of her normal sexy self.

Doug says: "Her hair looks nice pulled back, but I don't like the dress she's wearing. It looks like a costume from a high school musical."