Nicki Minaj

We say: We're all about statement accessories and red-carpet drama, but toting the Pope on your arm was a bit too extreme. It distracted us from what would have been a breath-taking beauty moment featuring Minaj's winged eyeliner, dewy skin, and glossy curls.

Will says: I liked it when I thought it a Little Red Riding Hood Play. It was fun and different, but not too Björk. The pope thing threw me off.